The only other consideration
concerning the power supply, is the orientation used
when mounting it in the TJ09. For the most
part, you're better off installing the power supply
in its normal “right-side up” position. If your
power supply has a bottom-mounted intake fan, it
will pull in cooler air through the grille
underneath. While this will certainly lower the
PSU's operating temperature (a plus), it will also
pull in dirt and dust—particularly if the case is
sitting on a carpeted floor (a minus). Plan on
blowing out your power supply with a can of
compressed air more frequently, as part of the
routine maintenance on your system.
What about inverting the power supply
so that it can help pull some of that video card
heat? Although the results probably won't be that
dramatic in lowering video card temperatures
(although every little bit helps), there's just one
problem. By inverting the power supply, you're
effectively shortening the distance between the
cables in the wiring harness and connectors on the
motherboard, by the width of the power supply
(the harness is now on the right instead of the
left). Unless your power supply has
longer-than-average cables, you may find that you
cannot connect the power cables to the motherboard
and other components. Due to the way the hard drives
are mounted in the drive bays, if you're using
fairly short SATA cables in your current case to
reduce cable clutter, you may need longer cables
after swapping everything into the TJ09—especially for drives mounted in the top bay.
Testing
We've only had a couple of cool, low
humidity days out here on the East Coast. Undaunted,
and with the help of my air conditioner, I coaxed
the room down to 68° and used
EVEREST Ultimate
Edition v4.00 (Build 976) to measure motherboard,
CPU (including each individual core) and the 8800
GTX’s temperatures under idle, and load. Having a
Logitech G15 Gaming Keyboard also allowed me to use
EVEREST Ultimate Edition's LCD applet to monitor
these temperatures on the G15 LCD in real-time. Idle
temperatures were recorded after allowing the system
to run for an hour at the desktop from a cold start.
Load temperatures were recorded while playing
The
Elder Scrolls 4: Oblivion for three hours straight.
For the second phase of testing I
removed as much extraneous noise from the room as
possible; then took my Galaxy Audio CM-130 SPL Meter
and placed it about the same distance that I
normally sit at the computer. I observed and
recorded the values from the CM-130 during system
boot, idle, and under load running the full battery
of benchmarks at the default settings with the
exception of the resolution set to 1920x1200 under
3DMark06 Advanced Edition v1.1.0. I recorded the
lowest and loudest readings then averaged the
results.
The same tests for temperature and
noise will be compared against the
Cooler Master
Stacker 830 NVIDIA Edition that I reviewed back
in January, with the same hardware configuration
used in the TJ09. To keep the tests consistent (and
fair), the Stacker tests were conducted using
the case’s out-of-the-box configuration of one 120mm
Cooler Master intake fan, and one 120mm Cooler
Master exhaust fan.
The SilverStone Temjin TJ09
and Cooler Master Stacker NV-830 are fairly close
in heat dissipation, although the NV-830 turned in better
numbers for the CPU under-load processor temperatures. I
suspect this has more to do with the fact that the
CPU no longer had the benefit of the Thermaltake
power supply’s 140cm fan to help remove some of the
heat, since it was now mounted at the bottom of the
case, than the relatively minor differences in
exhaust fan speeds (Cooler Master’s 1,220 RPMs to
SilverStone’s 1,200). The TJ09 would undoubtedly
benefit from an additional fan mounted in the rear
upper fan bracket to help pull some of the heat from
the CPU cooler outside the case.
There’s no doubt that the TJ09’s
video card cooling system does a better job than the
NV-830, which only has the benefit of passive
cooling through its mesh side panel without
additional fans installed. There were times while
playing Oblivion, when the GeForce 8800 GTX would
peak at 80°C
(a normal occurrence) before the card's fan would
immediately ramp up and drop the temperatures back
into the seventies. On average, this occurred much
less frequently with the TJ09, than the
Stacker NV-830. Noise (or more accurately, the
lack of it) is where the TJ09 really
stands out. The solid side panels and whisper-quiet
fans make a noticeable difference over the Stacker
NV-830. Even with the stock Intel cooler and GeForce
8800 GTX being the loudest components when under
load, overall the TJ09 is a noticeably quieter case
than the NV-830. Although the larger surface area of
the NV-830’s meshed side and top panels and the
ability to add more fans can easily give it a more
commanding lead over the TJ09 in keeping
things cool, it does so at the expense of more
noise. While it’s not likely that you would want to
want to lug either case to a LAN party, a fully
decked-out TJ09 is going to be easier on your back
(11 kg to the NV-830’s 16 kg) and your wallet (TJ09
street price -
$259;
Stacker NV-830 -
$299 from
the
NVIDIA Store).
Final Comments and Conclusion
By sticking with a classic design and
adding an innovative cooling system, the TJ09
is undoubtedly the finest case in the Temjin product
line to date. The fit and finish is impeccable, the
cooling is top notch; the case is super easy to get
in and out of, and it’s quiet. Cable
management can be a challenge, but not impossible
with a little planning and patience. If you have a
modular power supply, half the battle is already
won. Again, you’ll have to be mindful of cable
lengths—particularly power and SATA, but that’s true
of any case with a bottom-mounted PSU. The only
possible problem area I see with the case, is that
the motherboard tray's handle might interfere with
some video cable dongles and adapters, so you may
want to have some extender cables handy for those as
well.
I really like this case, and there’s
not much I would do to change it. I would add an
additional 120mm in the top rear fan bracket–one of
the “silent” models—to help pull some of the heat
from the CPU cooler, while keeping things as quiet
as possible The only thing I would have liked to have
seen SilverStone include, would be thumbscrews for
the expansion slots. I would have also liked the
motherboard tray and stand-offs designed identically
to the
SilverStone TJ03-B, which would have raised the
motherboard higher from the tray to allow easier
cable routing underneath it. I also think the front of the
case would look a little better with a smaller
SilverStone badge—but that’s just me…
The TJ09 isn’t a case for
everybody. If you’re not building a high-end rig
around one (or two) of NVIDIA or AMD’s flagship
video cards, there are better (and cheaper)
alternatives out there. But if you’re planning on
building a killer system where you can show off the
exotic plumbing of your water cooling setup through the
windowed side-panel, or prefer the "sleeper"
approach of the model with the regular side panel, the SilverStone Temjin TJ09
should be at the top of your list for your next
build.
Barry’s Rigs ‘n Reviews would like to
thank
Directron.com for making this review possible!
Final Score:
Summary:
Highs:
SilverStone takes their award-winning
line of Temjin-series cases to
the next level with the TJ09.
Clean, classic styling. Gorgeous
brushed aluminum finish and high-quality
construction throughout. Innovative hard
drive and video card cooling system.
Removable motherboard tray and roomy
interior free of sharp edges insures
hassle-free upgrades without having
paramedics on stand-by. Supports
full-length video cards and oversized
EPS 12V power supplies. Extensions for
front I/O Port connectors included.
Available with or without a side-panel
window. Quiet operation.
Lows: As with
any case that mounts the power supply at
the bottom, cable length could be an
issue depending on the layout of the
motherboard—particularly where the
4-pin ATX12V or 8-pin EPS12V auxiliary
power connectors are concerned.
Longer hard drive cables may also be
required depending on motherboard layout
as well. No thumbscrews for the
expansion slots. Motherboard tray handle
might interfere with some video cable
dongles.
Model: SST-TJ09B (black), SST-TJ09S (silver),
SST-TJ09B-W (black, with window), SST-TJ09S-W (silver, with window)
Material: 5.0mm aluminum front panel, 2.0mm
aluminum body
Motherboard: SSI, Extended ATX, ATX, Micro ATX
Drive Bay: External 5.25" x 4 3.5" x 1;
Internal 3.5" x 6 (vibration dampening)
Cooling System: Front 1 x 120mm fan slot
between HDD cages (optional); Rear 1 x 120mm exhaust fan, 1200rpm, 21dBA; Side
1 x 120mm mid-section fan, 1200rpm, 21dBA; Top 2 x 120mm fan slots
(optional)
Expansion Slots: 7
Front I/O Ports: USB2.0 x 2; IEEE1394 x 1;
audio jack x 1; MIC x 1
Full-length Video Card Support: Yes
EPS 12V PS Support: Yes
Power Supply: 1 x Optional standard PS2 (ATX)
or 1 x Redundant PS2